France Offers Asylum To Putin Critic Navalny
Russian opposition leader and outspoken Kremlin critic Alexey Navalny is in a coma after falling ill from suspected poisoning, his spokeswoman said Thursday.
Navalny, 44, started feeling unwell while on a return flight to Moscow from the Siberian city of Tomsk, his spokeswoman, Kira Yarmysh, said on Twitter. The plane later made an urgent landing in Omsk, she added.
Loud groaning can be heard in video footage apparently filmed on the flight taken by Navalny, which was shared on the Baza Telegram channel. More video apparently filmed through the airplane window shows an immobile man being taken by wheeled stretcher to a waiting ambulance.
He only drank black tea in an airport cafe before takeoff, Yarmysh told Russian radio station Echo of Moscow. “We assume that Alexey was poisoned with something mixed into the tea. It was the only thing that he drank in the morning. Doctors say the toxin was absorbed faster through the hot liquid,” Yarmysh tweeted.
Later on Thursday, Yarmysh said that Navalny still had not been diagnosed. “We don’t know what exactly caused everything that happened,” she said, adding that Navalny’s family and doctor had decided to move him to another facility, citing concerns for his safety as well as a lack of necessary equipment for testing.
“On top of that, this should be done as a safety measure,” she added.
Moving to an undisclosed location
Navalny was initially admitted to the acute poisoning unit of Omsk emergency hospital No. 1, where hospital head physician Alexander Murakhovsky said he was in “serious condition,” according to Russian state news agency TASS.
Asked by a reporter whether Navalny had been poisoned, the hospital’s deputy head physician, Anatoly Kalinichenko said: “Naturally, poisoning is considered as one of the possible reasons for the deterioration of his state. But apart from this, this could be a number of conditions that started acutely and led to the same clinical reactions. We are working on all of them: excluding, confirming.
In an earlier tweet, Yarmysh said the intensive care unit was full of police officers. “They try to get an explanation from the doctor. The doctor saw me in the distance in the corridor, said that ‘some things are confidential’ and took the police to another room,” she said.
“The evasive reaction of doctors only confirms that this is poisoning,” Yarmysh added.
Navalny’s attending physician, Anastasia Vasilyeva, said she had flown to Omsk after hearing the news of his hospitalization but had not been allowed to see Navalny or been given any information regarding his condition.
“We ask for help from the Ministry of Health and other officials to obtain documents [on Navalny’s condition], to determine the treatment and the need to transfer him to Moscow or abroad,” she posted on her Twitter account — a request echoed by Yarmysh’s statement, which urged the Omsk hospital “not impede with our obtaining all the documents required for his transportation.”
Yarmysh tweeted Thursday that Navalny’s wife, Yulia Navalnaya, had prevented Russian authorities from seizing her husband’s personal possessions.
“Yulia took Alexey’s things with her. She said that she did not allow them to be seized, and that they could only be taken as long as she’s arrested and there’s a subsequent personal search,” Yarmysh said.
Her tweet came shortly after another Navalny ally, Ivan Zhdanov, said investigators were taking Navalny’s personal belongings from Yulia, who had been visiting her husband in hospital.
Kremlin: ‘We wish him a speedy recovery’
Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said the Kremlin was aware of media reports about Navalny’s hospitalization.
“We know that he is in a serious condition. Doctors are now doing what is necessary. In Omsk, the best doctors are involved in this case,” he said on a regular conference call with journalists.
“They hold consultations with specialists from Moscow. Of course, like for any citizen of our country, we wish him a speedy recovery.”
Peskov said the Kremlin would be ready to consider any request for assistance from Navalny’s team should they ask about taking him abroad for treatment.
Asked if the Kremlin knows whether Navalny was poisoned with a hallucinogen, Peskov said the results of tests were still awaited.
“So far, as far as we know, there are no analysis results, so [these] are only assumptions about whether it was poisoning or not. This must be confirmed by laboratory tests,” Peskov said.
Western leaders responded with concern to reports of the suspected poisoning on Thursday.
French President Emmanuel Macron said his country was ready to offer Navalny “all necessary assistance” including asylum.
“We are obviously ready to provide all the necessary assistance to Alexey Navalny and his family, in terms of health, asylum and protection,” Macron said Thursday evening in a joint appearance with German Chancellor Angela Merkel.
The French leader called for “full clarity” on the circumstances of Navalny’s hospitalization.
“We will be extremely vigilant about the follow-up and the investigations that will be carried out. Above all, I hope that he can be saved,” Macron added.
German NGO The Cinema for Peace Foundation said it was sending a medical plane to Russia on Thursday night, in an attempt to evacuate the activist. However it is unclear if Russian authorities would allow Navalny to be medically evacuated to Germany.
“This is not political action, but a humanitarian effort,” Jaka Bizilj, the NGO’s founder said, adding that if the team evacuated Navalny he would be taken to Berlin for treatment at the city’s Charite clinic.
The anti-corruption activist’s team earlier said that documents allowing them to transport Navalny had yet to be granted to them.
Lithuanian Foreign Minister Linas Linkevicius described the reports of Navalny’s suspected poisoning as “very worrying” on Twitter.
“If confirmed, those responsible must face consequences. Closely following the situation, wishing him strength and speedy recovery,” he said.
UK Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab tweeted that he was “deeply concerned” by reports that Navalny “has been poisoned on a flight to Moscow and is now in a coma in intensive care.”
Health ‘sharply deteriorated’
More details are emerging of the events leading up to Navalny’s hospitalization.
Yarmysh told Russian media outlet Mediazona that Navalny had shown no signs of illness until after they had taken off from Tomsk.
“He said that he was not feeling well and asked me for a napkin, he had perspiration,” Yarmysh told Echo. “He asked me to talk to him because he wanted to concentrate on the sound of the voice. I talked to him, after which a trolley with water came up to us — I asked if water would help him; he said no. Then he went to the toilet, after which he lost consciousness.”
S7 Airlines told TASS that the opposition leader “did not eat or drink anything” during the flight.
“Soon after the takeoff of flight S7 2614 Tomsk-Moscow, the state of health of one of the passengers, Alexey Navalny, sharply deteriorated,” the company said.
According to S7, the crew “worked quickly and strictly in accordance with the procedures.” The flight attendants immediately reported the incident to the aircraft commander who landed the airliner at the nearest airport.
After refueling, the plane went on to Moscow but two passengers who were flying with Navalny stayed in Omsk, TASS said.
Investigation call
Lawyers representing Navalny’s Anti-Corruption Fund (FBK) will submit an application to Russia’s Investigation Committee demanding that it open a criminal investigation into his alleged poisoning, FBK lawyer Vyacheslav Gimadi wrote on Twitter.
“There is no doubt that Navalny was poisoned for his political position and activities,” Gimadi said.
Doctors did not find any signs of poisoning after doing analysis on the opposition leader, TASS reported last year.
In an interview with CNN’s Matthew Chance in 2018, Navalny said speaking out in Russia entailed a serious risk.
“Anyone who is engaged in opposition activities in Russia can be arrested or killed,” he said. “This thought gives me no pleasure or joy, I assure you, but it is a simple choice: you can be silent or you can speak. Taking into account all the risks, I continue my work.”
Poisoning claims
Other Kremlin critics or opponents have been involved in apparent poisoning incidents or suffered mysterious deaths.
Prominent investigative journalist Anna Politkovskaya, who was assassinated as she returned to her Moscow home in 2006, claimed in September 2004 that she had been poisoned with tea on a flight to Rostov as she attempted to reach Beslan, North Ossetia, to report on the school hostage crisis there.
Writing in The Guardian, she described how 10 minutes after drinking the tea, “I realise that I have to call the air stewardess as I am rapidly losing consciousness.” Politkovskaya says she was taken to a hospital, where she writes that a nurse told her: “My dear, they tried to poison you.”
A British inquiry found that two Russian agents poisoned ex-Russian spy Alexander Litvinenko at a London hotel bar in 2006 by spiking his tea with highly radioactive polonium-210. From his deathbed, Litvinenko insisted that Putin and the Kremlin were responsible for what happened. Moscow dismissed the inquiry as politically motivated.
In March 2018, former Russian agent Sergei Skripal and his daughter Yulia were poisoned in the English city of Salisbury in what British authorities assessed to be a nerve agent attack carried out by Russian military intelligence officers. Russia has denied any role in the poisoning.
Vladimir Kara-Murza, a vocal critic of Putin, said he was poisoned in 2015 and again mysteriously fell gravely ill in 2017. The Kremlin denied any involvement in Kara-Murza’s illness.
